Summary
The Apple Magic Keyboard for iPad Pro (M4 and M5) is widely regarded as the best keyboard case available for the iPad Pro, transforming it into a genuinely productive laptop-like device. Reddit sentiment is predominantly positive, with users praising the typing feel, backlit keys, and the extra USB-C port it adds. The main friction points are price — many find it too expensive — and weight, particularly on the 11-inch model where the bulk-to-screen-size ratio feels less justified. One key community insight: the M4 and M5 versions are hardware-identical, with Apple simply updating the branding; older pre-M4 keyboards are not compatible due to different magnet placement. Users with multiple devices (MacBook + iPad) debate whether it's truly worth the cost, while those who use the iPad as their primary work machine tend to call it essential.